As you begin your search for mutual funds, make sure that your performance evaluation produces meaningful results. Performance is important because good, long-term earnings enable you to maximize your investments and ensure that your money is working for you. Gauging future performance is not an exact science. When you evaluate funds, check out the Morningstar and ValueLine mutual fund newsletters, both available at the library or online (www.morningstar.com and www.valueline.com). A fund’s prospectus, which you can request from a fund’s toll-free phone number, also outlines the important features and objectives of the fund. As an additional check on your selection process, compare all your choice funds before making a final decision; avoid choosing one fund in isolation. A single fund can look spectacular until you discover it trails most of its peers by 10%. Look for the following information when you select mutual funds:
- One-, three-, and five-year returns: These numbers offer information on the fund’s past performance. A look at all three can give you a sense of how well a fund fared over time and in relation to similar funds.
- Year-to-date total returns: This is a fund’s report card for the current year, minus operating and management expenses. The numbers can give you a sense of whether earnings are in line with competing funds, out in front, or trailing.
- Maximum initial sales charges, commissions, or loads: Unlike stocks and bonds, mutual funds have builtin operating and management expenses. These expenses are in addition to any commission you may pay to a broker or financial planner to buy a fund. A sales charge on a purchase, sometimes called a load, is a charge you pay when you buy shares. You can determine the sales charge (load) on purchases by looking at the fee and expense table in the prospectus. No-load funds don’t charge sales loads. There are no-load funds in every major fund category. However, even no-load funds have ongoing operating and management expenses. Go for lower-priced funds or no-load mutual funds, which by definition must have expenses no higher than 0.25%. Load funds can have charges of up to 5.75%. What that means is that you must deduct that 5.75% from any annual performance a fund turns in. If it’s 10%, you can expect to earn 4.25% after you pay the load or commission.
- Annual expenses: Also called annual operating expense ratios (AOERs), these costs can sap your performance. Before you settle on one fund, review the numbers on at least a few competitors to determine if the fund’s expenses are in line with typical industry charges. In general, the more aggressive a fund, the more expenses it incurs trading investments. Before you invest in a particular fund, be cautious if it has an extremely high AOER compared to that of similar funds. To develop a sense of how expenses can take a big bite out of earnings over the years, consider this example: A $10,000 investment earns 10% over 40 years with a 1% expense ratio, which yields a return of $302,771. The same investment with a 1.74% expense ratio returns $239,177, or $63,594 less.
- Manager’s tenure: Consider how long the current fund manager (or managers) has been managing the fund. If it’s only been a year or two, take that into consideration before you invest — the five-year record that caught your eye may have been created by someone who has already moved down the road. Fund managers move around a often. In an ideal world, your funds are handled by managers with staying power.
- Portfolio turnover: This tells you how often a fund manager sells stocks in a the course of a year. Selling stocks is expensive, so high turnover over the long run will probably hurt performance. If two funds appear equal in all other aspects, but one has high turnover and the other low turnover, by all means choose the fund with low turnover.
- Underlying fund investments: For your own sake, take a look at the top five or ten stocks or bonds that a fund is investing in. For example, a growth fund may be getting its rapid appreciation from a high concentration in fairly risky technology stocks, or a global fund may have more than 50% of its holdings in U.S. stocks. Neither of these strategies is a mortal sin if you know about and can live with it. If you can’t, keep looking for a fund that matches your goals. Looking at underlying investments not only helps minimize your surprises as markets and economies shift, but also enables you to create a balanced portfolio.